From pizza to pasta to subs, we have a variety of menu items that can satisfy any appetite.

“The Pie Is The Limit”

Anthony’s New York Style Pizzeria, in Greencastle, IN, is the hottest and most delicious pizza in town. From pizza to pasta to subs, we have a variety of menu items that can satisfy any appetite. Our new location is perfect for local residents and DePauw students to have carry out, dine in or delivery. We are locally owned and operated, so you can be assured you will be treated like family, with complete satisfaction.

Testimonials

got a pizza here on their first day of business and I'll definitely be going back. just tried a simple half cheese half pepperoni since I wasn't sure yet. it was ready to go fast and the pizza was delicious. crust was cooked very well though could have been a bit crispier. the sauce was great as were the cheese and herbs.

I'll definitely keep going, their subs and calzones look awesome in addition to their good selection of pizza toppings and styles

<<
>>

Recommended

The Anthony

14″ – 15.75

16″ – 19.25

18″ – 22.75

Check our menu